eJ.D.E. ISSN 1776-2960
 

Evaluation by a Board Member
Your evaluation is indispensable. Please fill the text fields and evaluate the author’s propositions using the criteria that we propose below. Your evaluation will be anonymously passed on to the author (double blind)
Reviewer(not printable area)    
 
 
Family Name      : eMail  :
First Name :

                Your evaluation of the submission (printable area)      

Title :

Your opinion for process editor
  For submission review   No publication

Handling of the subject by the author : (Printable area)          
Formulated hypothesis
(The question is .... )
  No question
  Present  but confusing

  Clearly written
  Relevant
  Original
Proof demonstration(s)
(The  proof is ....)
  No investigation to discuss
  Present
  Acceptable
  Rigourous
  Original
 
Attained result
 (The result is … )
  Absent
  Present but vague
  Acceptable
  Relevant
  Original
Proposed argumentation (s)
 (Argumentation is ...... )
  No argument
  Present but vague
  Acceptable
  Rigourous
  Original
Summary of your appreciation
 ( Max 5 lines)
 
Advices for the author(s)
Possible improvements or corrections if necessary  (Max 15 lines )